Written and sourced by Vincent Wesley Couey, RxGrab founder. Updated .
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
GoodRx and Cost Plus Drugs both promise to cut your prescription costs. But they work in completely different ways, and the "cheaper" option changes depending on what drug you need, how quickly you need it, and where you live. We priced common generics from Cost Plus's own price list and Walmart's published list, and we say below where we did not read GoodRx. For more context on how these fit into the broader pharmacy landscape, see our complete pharmacy comparison.
Here's the core tension: GoodRx is a coupon aggregator that makes money from pharmacy transaction fees. Cost Plus Drugs is an actual pharmacy that makes money from a transparent 15% markup. These different business models produce different pricing advantages - and understanding which model favors your situation is the key to saving the most money.
GoodRx negotiates discount prices with pharmacies across the country. You search for your drug, pick the pharmacy with the best price, show a coupon, and pay the discounted rate. GoodRx makes money by taking a percentage from the pharmacy on each transaction. You fill at your local pharmacy - CVS, Walgreens, Walmart, Costco, wherever has the best price.
The GoodRx model has a built-in pricing quirk: since GoodRx takes a cut of each transaction, pharmacies factor that fee into the price they offer. The "discounted" price you see already includes GoodRx's margin. This doesn't mean the prices are bad - they're still far below retail - but it explains why some pharmacies offer lower cash prices than the GoodRx coupon price.
Cost Plus Drugs is an actual pharmacy. They buy medications from manufacturers, add a transparent 15% markup and a $5 pharmacy fee plus a shipping fee that starts at $5.25 for standard delivery, and mail them to you. There's no middleman negotiation - you see the exact cost breakdown. All orders ship from their Dallas, TX facility.
The pricing formula is simple and public: Manufacturer cost + 15% markup + $5 pharmacist fee + shipping (from $5.25) = your price. For a drug that costs the manufacturer $2.00 to produce, your price would be $2.00 + $0.30 + $5.00 + $5.25 = $12.55. This radical transparency is what attracted Mark Cuban to found the company - and why it has developed a devoted following among cost-conscious patients.
Cost Plus prices are from its own price list (read October 13, 2026) and include its $5 pharmacy fee; shipping is extra, $5.25 for an order of one or two prescriptions. The comparison column is Walmart's Prescription Program list (effective 03/24/2025), a flat published price. GoodRx's coupon price at your pharmacy is a third number that you check yourself; we did not read it for this page.
| Drug (30-day) | Walmart list | Cost Plus (listed) | Cost Plus, shipped alone | Lowest published price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atorvastatin 20mg | Not listed | $5.41 | $10.66 | Cost Plus shipped ($10.66) |
| Lisinopril 20mg | $9.00 | $5.56 | $10.81 | Walmart list ($9.00) |
| Metformin 1000mg (60 tablets) | $9.00 | $6.14 | $11.39 | Walmart list ($9.00) |
| Amlodipine 10mg | $9.00 | $5.30 | $10.55 | Walmart list ($9.00) |
| Sertraline 100mg | $9.00 | $6.04 | $11.29 | Walmart list ($9.00) |
| Losartan 50mg | $9.00 | $5.51 | $10.76 | Walmart list ($9.00) |
| Levothyroxine 50mcg | $4.00 | $5.91 | $11.16 | Walmart list ($4.00) |
On a single 30-day fill, Walmart's list was at or below Cost Plus shipped on 6 of the 6 drugs it lists, because $5.25 of shipping is large next to a drug that costs a few dollars. Drugs Walmart does not list are where Cost Plus is the only published price in the table. This changes with 90-day supplies:
| Drug (90-day) | Walmart list | Cost Plus (listed) | Cost Plus, shipped alone | Lowest published price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atorvastatin 20mg | Not listed | $6.23 | $11.48 | Cost Plus shipped ($11.48) |
| Lisinopril 20mg | $24.00 | $6.68 | $11.93 | Cost Plus shipped ($11.93) |
| Amlodipine 10mg | $24.00 | $5.91 | $11.16 | Cost Plus shipped ($11.16) |
| Sertraline 100mg | $24.00 | $8.11 | $13.36 | Cost Plus shipped ($13.36) |
| Losartan 50mg | $24.00 | $6.54 | $11.79 | Cost Plus shipped ($11.79) |
| Levothyroxine 50mcg | $10.00 | $7.74 | $12.99 | Walmart list ($10.00) |
Cost Plus shipped alone was lower than Walmart's 90-day price on 4 of the 5 drugs Walmart lists, and shipping is charged once per order, so combining prescriptions spreads it further.
Take a patient on lisinopril 20mg, atorvastatin 20mg and amlodipine 10mg, shipped together as one three-prescription order ($7.50 standard shipping for 3 to 4 prescriptions):
| Strategy | Annual cost (3 drugs) |
|---|---|
| Cost Plus, one order a month (12 shipments) | $285.24 |
| Cost Plus, one 90-day order a quarter (4 shipments) | $105.28 |
| Cost Plus, 90-day orders shipped separately, $5.25 each | $138.28 |
| Walmart list, 90-day fills of the 2 of these drugs it lists (4 a year) | $192.00 (atorvastatin is not on the list) |
The quarterly combined order is the cheapest row: $105.28 a year for all three, or about $8.77 a month. A GoodRx coupon price at your local pharmacy is the number to put next to it; we have not read it for these drugs, so check it for yours.
The comparison above uses the cheapest generics on the market, which every pharmacy prices aggressively. The real differentiation shows up on moderately expensive generics where pharmacies keep higher margins, and where Cost Plus's formula leaves a fixed fee on a bigger base:
| Drug (30-day) | Cost Plus (listed) | Cost Plus, shipped alone | Walmart list |
|---|---|---|---|
| Imatinib 400mg | $34.50 | $39.75 | Not listed |
| Bupropion XL 300mg | $6.68 | $11.93 | Not listed |
| Finasteride 5mg | $6.16 | $11.41 | Not listed |
| Tadalafil 20mg (30ct) | $6.68 | $11.93 | Not listed |
For these drugs the $5.25 of shipping is small against the drug cost, and Walmart does not publish a price. Put your GoodRx coupon price next to the Cost Plus figure before you decide. For where the large generic price gaps come from, see our brand-to-generic patent-cliff audit.
| Factor | GoodRx | Cost Plus Drugs |
|---|---|---|
| Fill location | Any local pharmacy | Mail-order only |
| Speed | Same day | 5-7 business days (standard, after 2-3 day processing) |
| Controlled substances | Yes (at local pharmacy) | No |
| Brand-name drugs | Yes (limited discounts) | Limited (mostly generics) |
| Price transparency | Moderate (price shown, not cost breakdown) | Full (manufacturer cost visible) |
| Insurance integration | Can compare vs. insurance | Mostly cash; in-network with some plans |
| Refill convenience | Manual each time | Auto-refill available |
| Cost to use | Free (paid tier: Companion, $14.99/mo) | Free |
| Drug catalog size | Thousands (nearly everything) | ~2,500 generics |
| Temperature-sensitive drugs | Yes (local pickup) | Limited (cold-chain shipping) |
If you're self-employed and managing healthcare costs carefully, both tools should be in your toolkit. CeoCult covers the broader picture of managing healthcare costs as a freelancer. Whichever pharmacy you choose, always check your medications for interactions before starting something new. OmniRx's drug interaction guide walks you through the process and offers a free interaction checker tool.
Cost Plus's shipping fee, which starts at $5.25 for standard delivery, is the single biggest factor that makes it less competitive on cheap 30-day generics. When your medication costs $1.50 wholesale, the shipping fee more than triples the total price. Two strategies minimize this impact:
1. Order 90-day supplies. The standard shipping fee applies once per order, so a larger order spreads it thinner. A 90-day supply of atorvastatin 20mg is listed at $6.23 (including the $5 pharmacy fee) plus $5.25 shipping, $11.48 in all, or about $3.83 a month. Three separate 30-day Cost Plus orders cost $5.41 plus $5.25 shipping each, $31.98 in all. Adding the 90-day order to a combined shipment (strategy 2) narrows the cost further.
2. Combine multiple prescriptions into one shipment. Cost Plus ships all your medications together on one order. Standard shipping is tiered by prescription count ($5.25 for 1-2, $7.50 for 3-4, $9.50 for 5-6), so consolidating spreads that single shipping charge across more drugs. The more prescriptions you consolidate, the better the per-drug economics.
A patient filling four 90-day prescriptions together through Cost Plus pays one tiered standard shipping charge per quarter (around $7.50 for a 3-4 prescription order), a modest yearly total compared to the drug cost savings.
Cost Plus Drugs focuses on generics and has been steadily expanding their catalog. But there are important gaps:
If your medication isn't on Cost Plus, GoodRx is your fallback. Check Cost Plus's full catalog at costplusdrugs.com before making assumptions - they add new drugs monthly.
These aren't mutually exclusive. The smartest approach:
The shipping fee is charged per order, not per prescription, so a household that ships together pays it once. Consider two adults who together take lisinopril 20mg, atorvastatin 20mg, amlodipine 10mg and sertraline 100mg, ordered as one four-prescription Cost Plus shipment ($7.50 standard shipping):
Consolidation is the lever: the 90-day combined order costs $220.00 a year less than monthly shipments of the same drugs. A paid GoodRx plan for a family only makes sense if its price on your drugs saves more than the plan costs.
GoodRx's paid tier (Gold, now sold as Companion at $14.99 a month) adds a second negotiated rate. It pays off only if it saves you more than $14.99 a month over the free coupon: at $1 saved per fill you would need 15 fills a month. For most people the free version is sufficient, especially if you use Cost Plus for maintenance medications. Check the paid price against the free price on every drug you take before you subscribe.
Paid tiers change over time, so confirm the current price and what it covers on GoodRx's own page before subscribing.
No. For a single 30-day fill of a common generic, a local price often wins because Cost Plus adds shipping from $5.25. For 90-day supplies, combined shipments and less common generics, Cost Plus's published prices are often the lowest. The winner varies by drug and quantity, so check both.
You can use both services, but not on the same prescription fill. GoodRx is used at local pharmacies; Cost Plus is a separate mail-order pharmacy. You might fill some prescriptions through Cost Plus and others at a local pharmacy using GoodRx coupons.
No. GoodRx only shows prices at partner retail pharmacies. Cost Plus Drugs is a separate, independent pharmacy that doesn't participate in GoodRx's network. You need to check costplusdrugs.com separately.
Cost Plus takes 2-3 business days to process an order, then standard shipping takes 5-7 business days from their Dallas, TX facility. Expedited shipping (2-4 business days) is available for an added fee. First-time orders may take slightly longer because of prescription transfer and verification. Plan ahead for refills - set up auto-refill so orders ship automatically before you run out.
Mostly no. Cost Plus is cash-pay for most customers, though it is now an in-network pharmacy for some insurers and PBMs, so check your plan. In many cases, their cash prices are lower than insurance copays anyway - especially for patients with high-deductible plans. But if your insurance copay is $1-$3, insurance will beat Cost Plus on most generics.
Yes. You can transfer prescriptions directly through the Cost Plus website. They'll contact your current pharmacy to handle the transfer. You can also ask your doctor to send a new prescription to Cost Plus Drugs. The process typically takes 1-3 business days for the transfer, then another 2-3 days to process plus 5-7 days for standard shipping.
We have not started sending yet. Join the list and we will only email when we do.
Prescription prices in the United States are set through a documented chain of list prices, pharmacy benefit contracts and federal programs, and the sources below are the primary public records of how that chain works. They are linked so a reader can check a claim here without taking this page's word for it.
This page describes how prescription pricing and discount programs work. It is not medical advice, and what a given person pays depends on their own plan, pharmacy and prescriber.